Tennessee Center for Performance Excellence | Baldrige Asks for Criteria Feedback and We’re Breaking it Down

01 Sep Baldrige Asks for Criteria Feedback and We’re Breaking it Down

Posted at 01:42h in Uncategorized by Emily

We were excited to see that the Baldrige Program has been in the process of seeking input needed to revise the Baldrige Excellence Framework® to keep it on the leading edge – we are in the business of continuous improvement after all! And much like we have been doing over the last few years, they are seeking to simplify the process without losing its efficacy.

To maximize their efforts, Baldrige met with experts and master examiners across a variety of sectors to ask for revisions and feedback; reviewed literature and benchmarking of other excellence programs; and interviewed Baldrige consultants on where their clients’ pain points and key benefits lie in the Framework.

In a series of webinars, Baldrige leaders raised discussions on a variety of topics that are impacting organizations now and in the future. Much of the related feedback on the Criteria could be sorted into three main buckets: transformation, supply network, and innovation. We will be interested to see how and if these items appear in the next iteration of the Criteria, expected in late 2022 or early 2023!

Advanced Technology, Disruptive Technology, & Predictive Analytics
Award Process Improvements & Simplification
Incorporating Lessons from Covid into the Criteria
Virtual/Hybrid Working Environments
Changing Leadership
Supply Network Challenges & Reliance
Consideration for New Organizational Metrics: SDGs, ESG, Drucker Institute, etc.
Workforce Issues & Vulnerabilities

Read the full article on Blogrige and see how you would answer some of the questions they posed!

Print page

Category	Points	Level 4 50 pgs.	Level 3 35 pgs.	Level 2 15 pgs.
1 \| Leadership	120	7	4.2
2 \| Strategic Planning	85	4	2.9	1.3
3 \| Customer Focus	85	5	2.9	1.3
4 \| Measurement, Analysis, Knowledge Management	90	4	3.2	1.3
5 \| Workforce Focus	85	4	2.9	1.3
6 \| Operations Focus	85	6	2.9	1.3
7 \| Results	450	20	16	6.7
Totals	1,000	50	35	15

Assessment Level	Number of Employees	*Site Visit/Workshop Fee -** Member	*Site Visit/Workshop Fee -** Non-Member
Excellence Award (Level 4)	Less than 100	$2,160	$2,700
	100-500	$3,120	$3,900
	501-1,500	$5,040	$6,300
	More Than 1,500	$6,000	$7,500
Achievement Award (Level 3)	Less than 100	$1,920	$2,400
	100-500	$2,640	$3,300
	501-1,500	$4,080	$5,100
	More Than 1,500	$5,280	$6,600
Commitment Award (Level 2)	Less than 100	$1,680	$2,100
	100-500	$2,400	$3,000
	501-1,500	$3,840	$4,800
	More Than 1,500	$5,040	$6,300
Interest Award (Level 1)	Less than 100	$680	$850
	100-500	$920	$1,150
	501-1,500	$1,400	$1,750
	More Than 1,500	$1,880	$2,350

Number of Employees (Full-Time Equivalent)	Workshop Fee (L1) / Application Fee (L2,3,4) Member	Workshop Fee (L1) / Application Fee (L2,3,4) Non-Member
Less than 100	$920/$1,600	$1,150/$2,000
100-500	$1,640/$3,040	$2,050/$3,800
501-1,500	$2,600/$4,960	$3,250/$6,200
More Than 1,500	$3,800/$7,360	$4,750/$9,200

Assessment Level	Number of Employees	Intent to Apply / Administration Fee	Application/Workshop Fee - Member / Non-Member	Site Visit/Workshop Fee* - Member / Non-Member	Total with 20% Member Discount	Total at Regular Rate
Excellence Award (Level 4)	Less than 100	$250	$1,600/ $2,000	$2,160/ $2,700	$3,610	$4,450
	100-500	$250	$3,040/ $3,800	$3,120/ $3,900	$6,010	$7,450
	501-1,500	$250	$4,960/ $6,200	$5,040/ $6,300	$9,850	$12,250
	More Than 1,500	$250	$7,360/ $9,200	$6,000/ $7,500	$13,210	$16,450
Achievement Award (Level 3)	Less than 100	$250	$1,600/ $2,000	$1,920 / $2,400	$3,320	$4,150
	100-500	$250	$3,040/ $2,000	$2,640/ $3,300	$5,480	$6,850
	501-1,500	$250	$4,960/ $6,200	$4,080/ $5,100	$8,840	$11,050
	More Than 1,500	$250	$7,360/ $9,200	$5,280/ $6,600	$12,440	$15,550
Commitment Award (Level 2)	Less than 100	$250	$1,600/ $2,000	$1,680/ $2,100	$3,130	$3,850
	100-500	$250	$3,040/ $3,800	$2,400/ $3,000	$5,290	$6,550
	501-1,500	$250	$4,960/ $6,200	$3,840/ $4,800	$8,650	$10,750
	More Than 1,500	$250	$7,360/ $9,200	$5,040/ $6,300	$12,250	$15,250
Interest Award (Level 1)	Less than 100	$250	$920/ $1,150	$680/ $850	$1,850	$2,250
	100-500	$250	$1,640/ $2,050	$920/ $1,150	$2,810	$3,450
	501-1,500	$250	$2,600/ $3,250	$1,400/ $1,750	$4,250	$5,250
	More Than 1,500	$250	$3,800/ $4,750	$1,880/ $2,350	$5,930	$7,350

Requirement	Commitment Award (Level 2)	Achievement Award (Level 3)	Excellence Award (Level 4)
Intent to Apply/Eligibility Form	REQUIRED FOR ALL Submit by May 31 Intent to Apply due with $250 non-refundable fee
Organization Profile	REQUIRED FOR ALL 5-page maximum The Organizational Profile is submitted along with the Application Form, Application Fee, and Criteria Response. (see below)
Application Form & Fee	REQUIRED FOR ALL Submit by July 15 Applicants must use the Application Form via tncpe.org.
CEO Signature	REQUIRED FOR ALL
Criteria Response	1. Organizational Profile 2. Basic Item Questions 15-page maximum One electronic copy saved in PDF format	1. Organizational Profile 2. Overall Item Questions 35-page maximum One electronic copy saved in PDF format	1. Organizational Profile 2. Multiple Item Requirements 50-page maximum One electronic copy saved in PDF format
Site Visit*	One day, plus half-day workshop**	Two days	Three days
Recognition Eligibility	Commitment or Interest	Achievement, Commitment, or Interest	Excellence, Achievement, Commitment, or Interest
Applicant Responsibilities		Provide at least one TNCPE examiner*** Assistance to other organizations	Provide 2 or more TNCPE examiners† (a balanced combination of new and experienced) Assistance to other organizations Participation in annual Conference Best Practice tour

01 Sep Baldrige Asks for Criteria Feedback and We’re Breaking it Down

FREE – Introduction to Lean Six Sigma

Why consider a Green Belt or Black Belt to boost your career?

Announcing the 2023 TNCPE McWherter Leadership Award

Baldrige Releases Excellence Framework Update

2023 Excellence Conference Agenda

Baldrige Program Update

Page Allocation Table

Application Formatting

The Criteria response should follow these guidelines:

The Organizational Profile is a required part of all award applications and must be submitted along with the Application Form, Application Fee, and Criteria response.

A glossary of terms and abbreviations is highly recommended.

Site Visit Fee Table

Application Fee Table

TNCPE Assessment Fee Table

Application Requirements